Read further · read 98.3% · existing decipherment · partial

Montcalm to Paulmy, Québec, 4 November 1757: the cipher passages and a plan for Québec

The cipher paragraphs of Montcalm’s report to the war minister and his annexed sheet on the defence of Québec (SHD GR A1 3457, pièces 179–180), left out of the New York Colonial Documents edition, transcribed from the Library and Archives Canada copy with the decipherment written between the lines at the time, and translated. An officer’s verdict that the body of Louisbourg’s fortress is worthless, bread cut to a quarter-pound and horse for beef, and a plan to meet a landing between the Montmorency falls and the Saint-Charles. The War Department code was indexed from the same pairs: 318 numbers, two with unsettled digits kept out. Contributed by Andrew Beling, with AI agents.

Date
1757
Read now
98.3% of the cipher tokens give sense
Write-up
montcalm1757w.html
Files
targets/montcalm1757w
Open gaps
needs the archive ×2

Hand this page to your AI agent

Give your agent (Claude, ChatGPT or any assistant that can open web pages) this address and ask it to do the task on the page:

https://dbourdeau.github.io/cyphersolver/further/montcalm1757w.html

Or copy the block below into the chat. It is the whole task: the reading, every open gap, what has been tried, the steps, and how to report back.

TASK: take a partial decipherment further: Montcalm to Paulmy, Québec, 4 November 1757: the cipher passages and a plan for Québec
This page: https://dbourdeau.github.io/cyphersolver/further/montcalm1757w.html

You are helping a public research project finish reading historical cipher letters. This one is read in part:
the key works, but some pieces are still open. Your job is to close one or more of the open gaps below.

THE READING
  Write-up:   https://dbourdeau.github.io/cyphersolver/montcalm1757w.html (read it first: how the text was read, the key, the reading)
  Date:       1757
  Outcome:    existing decipherment · partial
  Read now:   98.3% of the deciphered cipher tokens give sense (pieces below may be untouched)
  Files:      https://github.com/dbourdeau/cyphersolver/tree/main/targets/montcalm1757w (NOTES.md, key, transcription, reading, scripts)

OPEN GAPS (from NOTES.md, "## Remaining gaps")
  1. [needs-physical-access: needs a new source] Unsettled 1757 numerals, p. 506 6?0 (670 or 690, read “rt”) and p. 518 2?5 (read “em”) - blocker: needs-physical-access; the LAC copy is ambiguous and the readers disagree, so both are withheld from the key; the French originals at Vincennes would settle them.
  2. [needs-physical-access: needs a new source] Conflicting 1757 values, chiefly 63 written over “s” where the usual reading is “vivres”: the sibling letters now show 63 = vivres and 83 = s throughout 1758, so this is a slip; whether the encipherer's or the copyist's - blocker: needs-physical-access (the original at Vincennes).

ALREADY TRIED (from NOTES.md, "## Escalation")
  [x] clear-pages: the period interlinear decipherments of both declared units located on LAC C-12578 and transcribed.
  [x] siblings: (14 Nov 2026): the War ministry copies on reels C-12577 to C-12579 (1756-1759) searched again in full by their OCR (every frame; figure-line scan loosened to three groups a line, and a search for "chiffr", "déchiff" and "sic pro"), hits checked by eye. No code W letter beyond the four already in `support/` (1756, May 1758, Sept 1758; Lévis 1759 is on the F3 reel) and no bare W passage was found. The four were aligned with their period decipherment using the 1757 index: same value on 502 of 526 indexed groups (9 May 1758), 19 of 20 (1756) and 36 of 37 (September 1758), but only 65 of 93 on Lévis's copy of 10 Nov 1759 p. 307, whose decipherment drifts against the figure lines; 52 groups not in the 1757 index get values in a separate table, `key/W_sibling_values.tsv`. Two new pieces of context: d'Argenson's minute of March 1756 sending Montcalm "un chiffre", and Montcalm's letter of 12 Apr 1759 whose copy gives the cipher passages in clear between brackets (no figures). See "Follow-up of 14 November 2026".
  [x] known-keys: (14 Nov 2026): W (1757 index plus sibling values) compared with every French code table of 1755-1760 held in the repository and with sheets e001295272 and e001295274: no table agrees above chance (largest: 1 exact agreement, against shuffled maxima of 2-3). No original W key located.
  [x] print: (14 Nov 2026): RAPQ 1924-25, 1925-26 and 1926-27 found on the Internet Archive and searched, with Casgrain's Lévis collection I-XII and his *Montcalm et Lévis* (1891), whitespace-normalised: none prints the 4 Nov 1757 cipher passages or the defence-of-Québec sheet. No claim that the text is unpublished everywhere.
  [x] key-rebuild: 318 clearly numbered values indexed from the period plaintext; conflicting values and uncertain digits withheld or qualified.
  [x] retry: (14 Nov 2026): both unsettled numerals looked at again on the full-size frames; neither is settled, and no sibling uses 670, 690 or an "em" group. The sibling letters settle the 63 conflict (63 = vivres five times in 1758, s = 83 eight times), so the 63 for "s" on p. 517 is a slip, not a homophone. A comparison with the French originals was not possible (not online).

STEPS
0. Set up. If you can run a shell, fork and clone the repository and work inside it:
     git clone https://github.com/dbourdeau/cyphersolver.git
   Then read, in this order: CONTRIBUTING.md (how a contribution is sent and credited); README.md, sections
   "Repository layout" and "Conventions" (how readings are measured and named); targets/montcalm1757w/NOTES.md in full, and the
   key, transcription and reading files it names; lang/README.md (shared language models).
   Work in targets/montcalm1757w/. Add your findings to NOTES.md under a dated heading without rewriting what is there, and
   update the "## Remaining gaps" line of every gap you close. Keep WORKLOG.md there: one dated line per step
   (hypothesis, value tried, solver run, crib, control), failures included. Do not edit docs/ (the site is generated).
   If you cannot run a shell, fetch the files from the links above and keep your work in files you send with the issue.
1. Pick a gap. Start with the ones marked "doable now" (open-codes, not-attempted, left-open): the images and the key
   are online, so they need only work. A gap marked "needs a new source" (no-key-material, too-short, illegible,
   needs-physical-access) can be closed only by something new: a key
   or a deciphered sibling found elsewhere, a better image, a printed edition or calendar, a photograph from the archive.
   For those, search for that material first, and say where you looked even when you find nothing.
2. Start from the existing key and transcription in the folder. Do not rebuild the key from scratch, and do not
   re-read parts that are already read unless you find an error in them.
3. For a code group or sign value: list every place the group occurs, show how each reads with the value you propose,
   and say what still does not fit. For a passage: re-read it at the image and give the folio and line. For a missing
   letter or leaf: say where it is held and how it can be reached.
4. Measure again. Apply the key to the whole text, write the reading file, and count the share of cipher tokens that
   give sense (not an estimate). The reading is "complete" only when (1) at least 95% of its cipher tokens give sense;
   (2) no gap is left untried; (3) every letter in it is covered; (4) what stays open is scattered code groups or names,
   or pieces blocked from outside. Otherwise it stays "partial": say which gaps are still open and why.
5. Be honest. Mark every uncertain word with [?], leave unread groups as their numbers or signs, and never fill a gap
   with a plausible guess. A gap retried and still open, with what was ruled out, is worth reporting.

REPORT BACK
With a clone: open a pull request with your changes to targets/montcalm1757w/. Say in the description which gaps you worked on,
  the share read before and after, and how you want to be credited (name, initials or handle, and a link).
Without one: open an issue: https://github.com/dbourdeau/cyphersolver/issues/new?template=further-reading.yml&title=Further+reading%3A+montcalm1757w&page=montcalm1757w.html
  Give the write-up, the gap you worked on (its line in Remaining gaps, or the code group, folio and line), what you
  propose, the evidence (every occurrence, the images or sources), the share read before and after, your step log,
  and the tools and AI model you used.
If you cannot open issues or pull requests, write this report for your human to send. Credit goes to the person who sends it.

Open gaps

gold can be done now: the images and the key are online, it needs only work. grey needs a new source first: a key, a better scan, an edition or the archive.

Already tried

Send a result

One closed gap counts: a code group valued, a passage re-read, a key or clear copy found elsewhere. It is credited to you on the write-up.

Open a further-reading issueOther kinds of reportHow credit works← All partial readings